RentRedi vs TurboTenant (And Why 4M Users Choose RentSpree)

Trying to decide between RentRedi vs. TurboTenant? Maybe you’ve encountered them through a landlord community, a property investing forum, or a search for property management software. We've done the work to break them down side by side across screening coverage, pricing, and features. We've also added RentSpree to the mix—and if you haven't come across it yet, it's worth a look: broader criminal background coverage, comprehensive screening features (typically free to landlords and agents), and more verified reviews than either platform.

Quick verdict: 6 reasons to pick RentSpree over RentRedi and TurboTenant

1. More than 4 million users, 300+ industry partners, and more MLS integrations than RentRedi or TurboTenant. RentSpree (that’s us) has 72 direct MLS integrations and partnerships with REALTOR® Associations and brokerages nationwide—embedded directly into the workflows agents and landlords use every day. RentRedi has discount partnerships with investor communities like BiggerPockets and a member benefit deal through NAR, but neither puts RentRedi inside an agent's actual listing or transaction workflow. TurboTenant has no equivalent partnerships. 
2. A complete toolkit for both agents and landlords. RentRedi and TurboTenant focus on landlords while RentSpree serves the rental market more broadly. For agents, RentSpree offers a screening workflow that plugs directly into MLS listings—no separate tool or extra step required. For landlords, rent collection and bookkeeping are included on the free plan, with e-sign, waived ACH fees, and financial reporting available starting at $6.99/month with Landlord PRO—about half the cost of TurboTenant and RentRedi's mid-tier plans.
3. The widest criminal background coverage of the three. RentSpree runs criminal checks in 37 states plus D.C. RentRedi covers 30. TurboTenant covers 24. For landlords in Alabama, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New York, or South Carolina, RentSpree is the only option that returns criminal data.
4. Income verification on any plan, no annual commitment. In 2026, income verification is table stakes for any landlord hoping to avoid applicant fraud. RentRedi ties screening access to a monthly subscription, while TurboTenant ties income verification to a $199/year plan. RentSpree makes bank-verified income checks available on every plan for a simple $10 applicant-paid add-on—nothing extra required from the landlord.
5. Adverse action, handled. Sending an FCRA-compliant adverse action notice isn't optional—skip it and you're looking at up to $1,000 in statutory damages per violation. RentSpree generates and sends the notice in one click. RentRedi and TurboTenant both leave this step to the landlord.

The strongest review profile of the three. RentSpree's 4.6 Trustpilot rating across 934 reviews reflects consistent satisfaction at scale. TurboTenant holds a 4.5 across 537 reviews. RentRedi's 3.8 across 224 reviews includes a notable share of complaints around payment processing and platform reliability

RentRedi vs TurboTenant (Plus RentSpree): by the numbers

At a high level, here’s a quick view into how the three platforms differ on who they serve and how widely they're used.

RentRedi vs TurboTenant (Plus RentSpree): Tenant screening comparison 

When it comes to screening, the differences between these three platforms go beyond price. Here's how the coverage, speed, and features stack up side by side.

RentRedi vs TurboTenant (Plus RentSpree): Pricing and plan comparison 

Each platform takes a different approach to pricing. RentSpree and TurboTenant both offer free entry points, while RentRedi starts at $5/month. Here's how the plans compare.

*Most tenant screening platforms give you the ability to pass screening fees to the applicant. However, certain jurisdictions prohibit this. Check your local rules before doing so.

Key differences

Here's where RentSpree pulls ahead of TurboTenant and RentRedi:

1. RentSpree works for agents and landlords, giving it broader reach into the rental market

RentSpree is the only platform of the three designed to serve every side of the rental transaction. For agents, an ApplyLink™ generates automatically when a rental is listed—screening kicks off without a separate tool, and applications flow in through any channel including directly from the MLS listing. For landlords working with an agent, that same workflow means screening, lease signing, and rent collection all happen in one shared place, with reports and documents accessible to everyone who needs them. For landlords self-managing, RentSpree provides the full toolkit from listing to lease to payment collection without stitching together separate tools.

2. RentSpree has the largest user base, most MLS reach, and strongest review profile

RentSpree wins out on scale and trust. RentSpree has 4 million users, 72 direct MLS integrations, and 300+ MLS, REALTOR® Association, and brokerage partners—more embedded distribution than any other screening platform in the country. TurboTenant has reached 1 million users through direct-to-landlord growth, with no MLS partnerships. RentRedi has around 200,000 users and similarly no MLS integrations.

RentSpree holds a 4.6 Trustpilot rating across 934 verified reviews, 757 of which are five stars. TurboTenant sits at 4.4 across 537 reviews. RentRedi has a 3.8 rating across 224—the lowest of the three, with 22% of reviews being a single star citing complaints around payment processing failures, platform glitches, and poor customer service follow-through.

3. RentSpree's free plan includes screening—RentRedi's doesn't, and TurboTenant's has gaps

RentSpree's free plan includes tenant screening, leases, listings, and rent collection with no monthly fee at all. RentRedi's $5/month Start plan excludes screening, leases, listings, and maintenance requests entirely—those features require upgrading to the Grow plan at $12/month billed annually. TurboTenant's free tier does include screening, but draws the line at lease agreements and income verification. If zero monthly cost is the goal, RentSpree is the only platform where the full screening workflow is actually in the free tier.

4. RentSpree returns criminal background data in more locations than TurboTenant and RentRedi 

All three platforms use TransUnion for background checks, but the geographic reach of their criminal background checks varies significantly. RentRedi's coverage extends to 30 states. TurboTenant reaches 24 states. RentSpree's criminal background check is available in 37 states plus D.C., including Alabama, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New York, and South Carolina, where neither TurboTenant nor RentRedi offer any coverage at all.

RentSpree also supports conditional acceptance, a two-phase screening workflow required in certain jurisdictions where landlords must issue a preliminary approval before accessing full background check details. This matters in places like Cook County (IL), Detroit (MI), Montgomery County (MD), Oakland and Berkeley (CA), and Washington, D.C. Neither TurboTenant nor RentRedi offers an equivalent process.

5. RentSpree makes income verification available on any plan—no annual commitment required

RentSpree offers bank-verified income checks (via Finicity by Mastercard) on any plan, with applicants typically paying a $10 add-on on top of the standard screening fee—no subscription required on the landlord's end. RentRedi also offers Plaid-certified income verification as an add-on at $49.99 total (versus $39.99 without it), but screening itself requires at least the Grow plan at $12/month billed annually, so there's always a subscription in the picture. TurboTenant puts income verification behind the Pro plan at $199/year. Rental fraud is on the rise—fake pay stubs, doctored bank statements, and inflated income figures have made income verification a baseline part of responsible screening, not an optional extra.

6. RentSpree automates adverse action notices—the others leave it to you

The Fair Credit Reporting Act requires landlords to send an adverse action notice whenever a denial or change in rental terms is based on a screening report—and missing that step can cost up to $1,000 per violation in statutory damages. RentSpree builds this into the workflow: when you take an adverse action, a one-click notice sends directly from the applicant review dashboard, pre-populated with the reporting agency's details, required disclosure language, and the applicant's rights. TurboTenant offers a template and leaves execution to the landlord. RentRedi does not mention support for adverse action. 

Ready to see how RentSpree works?

Screen tenants, collect rent, and manage your rental from one place—no subscription required to get started.

Frequently asked questions

Here’s a few ways RentRedi and TurboTenant stack up against each other and trail behind RentSpree’s more cost-effective and thorough offerings: 

‍

‍